Monday, November 22, 2010

The worst day of our times Noveber 20, 1962

There have been bad days in independent India’s history—the day Mahatma Gandhi was shot, Indira Gandhi’s assassination and the massacres that rocked the capital, and 26/11. The Mahatma’s death was one with the paroxysm of freedom that took hundreds of thousands of lives, mainly in northern India. The assassination of Indira Gandhi and the Mumbai attack were shocking no doubt, but they do not have compare to the national collapse of 20/11 — to use the modern parlance — of 1962, almost exactly 58 years ago, down to the day.

Abandoned Indian vehicles, perhaps below Bomdila

 “The dawn of 20 November 1962 was the blackest in the military history of independent India,” says the unpublished official history of the 1962 war. “Yesterday (November 20) was the day of ultimate panic in Delhi,” wrote the then US Ambassador John Kenneth Galbraith in his India memoir.  According to Galbraith, the “wildest rumours” went around — that 500 Chinese paratroopers were about to land in Delhi, that Tezpur was about to fall to the Chinese. Of the rumour that Lt Gen B.M. Kaul, the hapless Corps Commander of the now disintegrated Indian army in the Northeast Frontier Agency was taken prisoner, Galbraith cited President S. Radhakrishnan’s tart retort, “It is, unfortunately, untrue.”

In Delhi it was only rumour but on the eastern front actual disaster loomed. At 3 am on November 20, the last fighting formation of the 4th Division, the 48th brigade, disintegrated under Chinese fire at Chaku. In Tezpur, 100 kms south, panic and chaos were the order of the day. Gen Kaul ordered abandonment of all positions on the northern bank of the Brahmaputra and moved his headquarters to Guwahati. The administration emptied hospitals, prisons and asylums then burned currency in the Treasury and official documents. “By nightfall,” the official history recounts, “Tezpur was a ghost city.”

That evening Prime Minister Nehru addressed the country saying, “huge Chinese armies” had inflicted serious reverses by capturing Walong, Se La, Bomdila . He declared that India would not rest till the invader had been pushed out of India and wanted the message to be heard by all, especially our “countrymen in Assam to whom our heart goes out at this moment.” Not surprisingly, in Assam it appeared that India planned to abandon them to the advancing Chinese.

Nehru's humourous pose has become farcical now. In the era of Google Earth, his heirs still disallow photography in airports.

India had suffered reverses in the war that began on October 20, 1962. Though it had lost Tawang, its forces were giving the Chinese a tough time in Chushul in Ladakh and in Walong in the north-eastern tip of the country. At Se La and Bomdila, east of Tawang, India had built up the 4th Division comprising of 12,000 men with 36 guns, light tanks and sufficient rations and ammunition, commanded by a decorated hero of World War II.
But in four short days, beginning November 17, this force had been taken apart, as much by the force of the Chinese attack as the incompetence of the commanders going all the way up from the division commander Maj Gen A.S. Pathania, to Corps Commander Kaul, and the Chief of the Army Staff P.N. Thapar who had been monitoring the battle from the Tezpur headquarters of Kaul’s division. More than anything else, this collapse seared national memory and defined the outcome of the 1962 war in the minds of most Indians.
Prime Minister Nehru did not learn of the disaster till late on November 19, the day Army Chief Thapar was relieved of his responsibilities.  Panditji had earlier written a letter to President Kennedy of the United States detailing events since October 20 and noted that the Chinese now controlled most of NEFA and were poised to overrun Chushul in Ladakh. He said that India wanted air transport and jet fighters as part of the US aid package if India was to “stem the Chinese tide of aggression.”
A few hours later he heard of the disaster of Bomdila and Se La, and said that the Chinese advance now threatened all of India’s Northeast, and that an invasion through the Chumbi Valley between Bhutan and Sikkim looked inevitable. He said that till now India had wanted essential equipment and not comprehensive assistance because, as he delicately put it, “of the wider implications of such assistance in the global context” viz India’s public non-alignment posture.
But he said the situation had now changed and that unless India was given massive assistance, there will be “nothing short of catastrophe for our country.” To this end he declared that India wanted assistance of 12 squadrons (roughly 200-240) of supersonic fighters, 2 squadrons of B-47 bombers and modern radar cover. Indian personnel would man the aircraft for missions over Chinese territory, while he wanted American personnel to “protect our cities and installations from Chinese air attacks.”

US Ambassador John Kenneth Galbraith in Leh

According to Nehru’s biographer S. Gopal, Nehru took this decision to seek a military alliance with the United States without consulting any of his Cabinet colleagues or officials except foreign secretary M.J. Desai. The US was not entirely enthusiastic about this proposal. Dean Rusk, Secretary of State, noted in a telegram to Galbraith on November 20, Nehru not only proposed “a military alliance between India and the United States but complete commitment by us to fighting a war.” The US which was aware of the Sino-Soviet split, was worried that an open commitment to India “might force Moscow to support Peiping.”
But on the morning of November 21, these considerations seemed to vanish into thin air. As Galbraith put it, “like a thief in the night, peace arrived.”
According to B.N. Mullik, the powerful Intelligence Bureau chief, he learnt of the Chinese ceasefire offer at 3 am from the monitoring station run by the agency which had recorded an announcement of Peking radio saying that the Chinese would ceasefire from the midnight of November 21. According to Neville Maxwell, Home Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri learnt of the ceasefire from the newspapers at the Delhi airport at 6 am, where he was waiting for a flight to take him to Guwahati.

The US aid, too, vanished. According to Mullik, the total aid promised to India by the end of December 1962 was $120 million, and later another $50 million in 1964, a total of some Rs 105 crore in the prevailing exchange rates. But by the time the programme ended, after a US embargo following the 1965 Indo-Pak war, the US provided a total Rs 40 crore worth of aid, mainly trucks, radars and communications equipment. A year later, British and American aircraft came to India and carried out a joint air exercise with the Indian Air Force. That was all that remained of the request for American air cover.
  The war’s principal outcome was to wake the nation from its pacifist slumber. The outpouring of patriotism was evident from the enormous donations that people made for the Defence of India Fund. Gold ornaments and jewellery donated then still lies forgotten in the vaults of the Reserve Bank of India. On November 13, the DMK supremo, C.N. Annadurai announced that the party was abandoning its secessionist platform and was pledged to support the government to push the Chinese out of India. Leaders of another proto-secessionist group, the Akali party, too, pledged support.
Mail Today November 21, 2010


Anonymous said...

and why did the chinese announced a ceasefire?

manoj joshi said...

As of now we can only speculate. 1) that the Chinese intended to "teach India a lesson" and puncture India's claim to be a leader of the Third World. Once they captured all of their claim area, they decided on ceasefire.
2)They were afraid that the conflict would draw in the US which had already stepped up its logistical assistance to India. At the time, China was not a nuclear weapons power and it would not have lightly contemplated conflict with the US.

sohan said...

is not the military top brass responsible for planning and projecting its needs to be prepared for combating intrusion by the enemy?

do we know if the military submitted detailed list of arsenal that it needs to be well prepared?

is it sufficient for the military brass i told you that there is a danger from China and not prepare the road map to face them if situation arises?

How did the military operation improve after the war? Was not the Kargil a repeat of 1962? Indian army was caught napping?

Anonymous said...

bro sohan...u got no idea whatsoever the way things are in india...we are a democracy.... the mil fights for the nation as n when the govt tells it to do so.. it doesnot do any decision making except how to fight a battle..itself...... the nations govt is what does its planning....whether govt is going to spend money on weapons etc is not a military decision..please wake up to realities of life n stop thinking that indian army is like pakistan army ...serving itself...we serve the nation ...and not the other way round.

Frank Sit said...

It's a wonderful way to be updated and active. People can see what is your activity and what you were doing recently. I think it's one of those new media on Internet. OUR BLOG FIOR MORE INFO.

Upadhyay Rathi Raj said...

Nehru thought himself as a statesman unparalleled and the wisest of all. He turned out to be utter failure where the national defence was concerned. He didn't even knew where and how his armies were!
A classic punishment to a nation whose leaders think like Nehru and who do not bother to learn diplomacy as well as art of war. Mr Nehru failed the nation at the most crucial juncture since he took reigns as the PM through deceit and after side-lining more able leaders who deserved to be PM.
He turned out to be absolutely ignorant and idiotic where national and international policies were concerned and was surrounded by men of his liking such as Menon, Mullick, etc. His death went unnoticed as the nation was not in the mood to forgive him.
More truths will crawl out of the government closet as time goes. His crying eyes at Lata Mangeshkar's song was to cover his own failures and cheat the entire nation.

Unknown said...

Some people say that the arrival of modern weaponry and support of US & UK, Chinese thought that the advantage chinese earned physically as well as psychologically would be lost once Indian Army start using those weapons, they were aware of the bravery of our troops, moreover Indian Army done well where they had advanced weaponry and strategically better places

Henry Edmundson said...

Dear Mr Joshi

I am writing a book on the Himalaya including its political history and would like to use with permission a photo on your website entitled "Abandoned Indian vehicles, perhaps below Bomdila". Would it be possible to get a high resolution scan of it.

Many thanks.

Henry Edmundson, Cambridge, UK